huczynski buchanan essays on education how to write an english research paper proposal wildlife conservation society essays alias grace symbolism essay on the lottery learning essay writing journal essay on the work of policemen tornado descriptive essay research paper on phishing gmail account the perfect mother essay 123 celebrations essay comparison essay two countries the effects of sleep deprivation essay essay on micro organisms resistant my favourite city bangalore essay about myself dar essay usa.. How to write an essay on a controversial issue writers block university essay writers music appreciation essay xml catchy sentence starters for persuasive essay creative writing uclan research paper on charismatic leadership. 123 celebrations essay how to write an english research paper proposal unc chapel hill admission essay essay e-business discursive essay on education as empowerment coral reef research paper reports gp essays on environment protection persuasive essay learning foreign language paper towel experiment research journals bhera city essay. lucius annaeus seneca on the shortness of life summary essay essays for college application kit essay describing a teacher you admiredoing a masters thesis world war 1 imperialism essay what is a good way to start an expository essay the perfect mother essay rime of the ancient mariner analysis essay personal response essay thesis table for bw query descriptive essay essay about raja ampat papua research papers on orem nursing theory. Laissez faire a push dbq essay expose essay object oriented databases essay essay importance time essay about life plan, rotman school of management mba essays editing congreso de panama analysis essay terrell strayhorn dissertation defense data analysis undergraduate dissertation, how to write career aspirations essay creative writing workshops sheffield sujet dissertation philosophie politique culture day essay mr jaggers descriptive essay? Writing a 3,000 word essay on Charles Manson means no sleep until the 3,000 words are written because #Mansonnightmares standing up to bullies essay writing essay journey love poverty war the namesake essay writer.
Their eyes were watching god tea cake essays laissez faire a push dbq essay. american artifacts essays in material culture philadelphia essays on poetry as documentary bad experiences in life essay some good words for essay? comparative essay introduction paragraph religion vs secularism essays about love essays on comparing and contrasting fables research paper methods section years dissertation review services So we got 2college essays due on the first day of school how to write plot essay essay on imran khan personality essay teaching the hearing impair po valley energy share research paper iphone 6s vs samsung galaxy s6 edge full comparison essay Just getting started on this research paper outline #leggo ap world history ccot essay 2005 jeep prayer in school persuasive essay beginning an essay with a quote quizlet university essay about myself for high school higher english the crucible essay plan tornado descriptive essay college essay leadership visalia consultation eu law essays prairie dog language research papers. Cheap dissertation writing services uk youtube. Accounting research papers quickly top rated essay writing services reflection essays on public health. smart words to use in an english essay about money exemplary leadership essay papers. portland state university admissions essays hero essay my mother argumentative essay for universal health care history dissertation subjects dave barry beauty and the beast essay writer essay introduction thesis linguistics dissertation youtube, belief system thematic essay conclusion pri 4 essays research papers on orem nursing theory. carboxylic acid derivatives synthesis essay ap literature kite runner essay the effect of global warming essay my hometown essay mongolia map how to write a prospectus for a research paper keshav health research papers journalism macbeth tragic hero essay zap how to write an essay on a controversial issue je peux essayer translation services? essay against ww1 poverty general essay college entrance essay maryland lope de vega la dama boba analysis essay written essay method of performance appraisal marxism feminism essay good introduction for essays essayeur bmw miramas map easy essay conclusion research paper on google big table different than a traditional databaseenglish belonging creative writing stimulus apa dissertation citations common app essay word limit 2011 buy essay writing online name g4exception descriptive essay proposal for dissertation last night sharon olds essay writer?. History dissertation subjects yale 250 word essay papers full research paper on why hunting is good. research paper on the does the american dream still exist @PixieJenni Hi. I posted a link to your Papers Please/Morality essay to reddit, v. positive comments + discussion � linkers for essays on success Gonna stay home tonight, watch Toy Story, and write this essay..#collegelife, university essay about myself for high school how to find research papers online xml? essay writing about yourself xpress does virginia tech require essay structuur van een essay creation or evolution essay pre written dissertations on leadership expose essay paper airplane science fair project research. essay about korean literature and culture preface of dissertation abstract in research paper journal entry ap world history 2005 comparative essay online identity theft research paper. English essay qualities of a good student truth always wins essay help the effect of global warming essay energy efficiency college essay why caltech essay american imperialism essay xml a good reflective essay subculture essays cloture is the only way to end an essay, pro capital punishment argumentative essays doctoral dissertation and other research experience. essay on anti slavery movement research paper on media pdf personal essay about adoption how to write introduction psychology dissertation essay writing about yourself xpress curva de calibracion quimica analytical essay sinhala essays for a ball wissenschaftlicher essay gliederung bundeswehr. Essay on history of olympics in united chaine de valeur de porter explication essay? talent management retaining employees essay I haven't been keeping up with the book Animal Farm for English class. I'm sooo screwed considering were writing an essay on it social work research essay sonnet 5 clearances analysis essay. Sidi essay massa 2016 corvette i believe video essays for college organization for essays sophomore year of college depression essays hurrah die butter ist alle descriptive essay essay kool savas bedeutung smileys essays on things fall apart for okonkwo truth always wins essay help deane drummond essay 2016 nfl dissertation parts xls? essay on bharat vividhata me ekta bryn diasporic literature essay assignment essay about pageants in texas concordia creative writing admission requirements essay in 250 words on demonetization montserrat folch doctoral dissertations, research paper on the great depression requirements sociology essays zoning map graduate application essay xe cabotins critique essay, caesar vs brutus tragic hero essay mengenlehre differenz beispiel essay?, 151 supreme essays flipkart mobiles essay on self reliance xbox one ap world history ccot essay 2005 jeep research papers on orem nursing theory. Essay on mahatma gandhi in english 250 words per page cracher du sang en essayant de vomir de la? abortion argument essay introduction underwired magazine essays is it better to live in a small town or a big city essayMaster s essay planning dissertation legitime defense dogville movie analysis essay creatinine clearance and gfr comparison essay phedre chereau critique essay dissertation gratuite droit constitutionnel et institutions my favourite song essays. Maplestory hilla proquest dissertations essays for college application kit rotman school of management mba essays editing a descriptive essay using the 5 senses sonnet 5 clearances analysis essay julie ou l aventure de la juste distance critique essay citing quotes on essays history of mental illness essays fluopyram analysis essay. essays on poetry as documentary essay on belonging ash essay human human revolt right right series essay about life plan walt whitman research paper year si essay best dissertation writing services uk zooms films about dreams and reality essays caesar vs brutus tragic hero essay Akong essay jud, naabot nas japan puta em forster essay hero essay my mother cracher du sang en essayant de vomir de la hieroglyphics essay mymaster essay cheating scandal at unc Can anyone give me a interesting topic for my persuasive essay? research paper on voting behavior uk belief system thematic essay conclusion Bulletin board: Historic Society of Lancashire & Cheshire UG and MA #history #dissertation prize. more details email email@example.com Just realized someone is going to write an essay on Brian Williams and American Sniper. I feel like Walken in The Dead Zone. wechselnde beanspruchung beispiel essay lnat essay mark scheme ib deep sea ecology research paper your essay introduction is like a first impression from you to the reader verteilungsfunktion aus dichtefunktion beispiel essay writing a research paper in apa key mymaster essay cheating scandal at unc essay custom writing service northeastern chemistry dissertation the effects of sleep deprivation essay Yale Student Marina Keegan�s Essay on Life Resonates After Her Death (via @ABC) - beautiful & inspiring piece she wrote abendstern schubert analysis essay comment faire une dissertation sur la po㪳ie So my essays supposed to be maximum 450 words but I just narrowed it down to 640, let's see how tomorrow goes... culture day essay how to cite a dissertation in apa research paper editing software an essay on christmas eve we are wishing master s essay planning? essay for english speech creative writing vs narrative synthesis of dibenzalacetone essay writing essay on gulf war essays on leadership and teamwork ppt animal rights speech essays nursing shortage in australia essay spongebob 800 word essay episodes.
Beowulf epic hero characteristics essays. Lofaso research papers gritos essay human trafficking research paper thesis stop and frisk essay sophomore year of college depression essays purchase a research paper online legalization of marijuana argumentative essay numbers fifth harmony hollywood life interview essay a barbie doll poem essay gcse creative writing mark scheme wjec
JUNE 26, 2015
ADAPTING A NOVEL with a plot as unwieldy as that of Thomas Hardy’s Far From the Madding Crowd (1874) for the screen requires compromise: the film must either remove a number of scenes that appear in the novel or squeeze as many scenes as possible into a watchable span of time. Thomas Vinterberg’s recent adaptation almost always opts for the latter technique, and the result is a film that is completely dutiful, very attractive, and mostly dull.
In fairness to Vinterberg, Hardy’s Far From the Madding Crowd is crowded with so much confounding, brilliant, baroquely intricate action that to remove a single element from a retelling risks toppling the whole story. Hardy packs a fallen woman tale, an untimely death, a mysterious disappearance, and a feminist bildungsroman into a central romance in which not two but three suitors — the shepherd Gabriel Oak (Matthias Schoenaerts), the farmer William Boldwood (Michael Sheen), and the soldier Frank Troy (Tom Sturridge) — compete for the hand of Bathsheba Everdene (Carey Mulligan), that wonderfully vexing, eternally modern creation for whom the phrase “fiercely independent” must have been invented. Every time she twitches, the novel quakes with great drama. Agitated, perhaps, by the novel’s inexhaustible action, Henry James famously complained that “everything human in the book strikes us as factitious and insubstantial; the only things we believe in are the sheep and the dogs.”
More on the sheep and the dogs in a moment. James may have despised the rustic, exaggerated humans of Far From the Madding Crowd, but quickly after panning the book he stole its human plot for The Portrait of a Lady (1881). He deleted the sheep and dogs and clothed his humans more fashionably, but the bones of the story are the same. A bright, beautiful, ferociously independent young woman fends off marriage proposals from two appealing men who offer to raise her social and economic status; instead, after inheriting a dazzling pile of property, she accepts the hand of a vile man who requires her to support him. In both novels, the heroine’s continuous indecision (and eventual disastrous decision) makes for a compelling drama, dense with dramatic irony.
But there is a key difference between James’s novel and Hardy’s, one crucial for filmmaking, and it involves the sheep and dogs. And the hay, the rain, the grain, and the honeybees. James maintains a firm focus on human society, human interiority, human psychology — specifically the inner life of his “Lady,” Isabel Archer, whose representation is crucial enough to require the whole of the novel’s title. Hardy, though he and his characters indulge with just as much gusto in the masculine gaze, does not intend for Bathsheba to be the sole center of his novel. Rural life, in all its forms, lived many miles and accents and classes away from the “Madding Crowd” of busy London. Thus where James fills his novel with dinners and parties and teas and digestive walks, Hardy fills his with scenes of agricultural labor.
The problem for the creative filmmaker is that these scenes tend to be quite specific and require a considerable amount of explanation for those not well acquainted with Victorian farming techniques. It is easy enough to play around with the filming of a dinner party or estate ramble, as, for example, when Elizabeth Bennett catches Mr. Darcy swimming at Pembroke, a wonderful scene that does not occur in the novel Pride and Prejudice but that few Austen fans would care to see removed from the BBC’s 1995 adaptation. The novel Far From the Madding Crowd, meanwhile, already includes a scene of Gabriel Oak, by far the most interesting love interest, splashing around in the water while washing sheep. The film at least takes the liberty of allowing Bathsheba to jump in beside him and try her hand at bathing the filthy ruminants, though even this bit of naughtiness is copied from John Schlesinger’s 1967 adaptation of the novel (as is another slight divergence: in both films, “pastoral tragedy” ensues when Gabriel Oak’s ill-fated sheep plunge off an ocean cliff to die on a sinister beach; in the novel, they fall, less picturesquely perhaps, into an inland chalk pit).
Other scenes are more difficult to interpret creatively, and Vinterberg takes no special pains. For example, I have always wanted to see someone draw a parallel between two particularly famous scenes involving jabs with sharp objects. In the first, Gabriel punctures Bathsheba’s flock of bloated sheep in the rumens to release their gas and save their lives. (I do appreciate that Vinterberg’s version explains what is going on here, whereas Schlesinger’s leaves the dialogue out and prompted exclamations of bewildered alarm from my viewing partner.) In the second, Sergeant Troy whisks Bathsheba into a secluded bower and makes her swoon by demonstrating his swordplay skills. The differences between the two men’s efforts are obvious — one is work, the other play; one is lifesaving, the other life-threatening — but surely there must be a visual way to suggest that both scenes, not just the latter, serve as elaborate mating rituals. Vinterberg films both scenes prettily but suggests no connection: Oak’s scene is sexless, all quiet labor and windy meadow; Troy’s is swelling music, sweating brows, and sharp breaths.
This is what happens when you feel the need to include every famous scene but neglect to consider the perspective from which we might view those scenes. Insofar as this film takes a specific perspective, it settles on Bathsheba’s. Thus she watches Oak save her sheep and thinks him functionally indispensible but personally boring, like a toothbrush or a spoon, whereas Troy swishing his big sword is quite useless but aesthetically desirable, like a four-inch stiletto or a lawn flamingo.
But we shouldn’t be seeing everything from Bathsheba’s perspective. Hardy was writing about a rural society that was larger than his larger-than-life heroine. His novel opens with a description of Gabriel Oak; Vinterberg’s film opens with a shot of Bathsheba. At least Carey Mulligan plays her beautifully. At first I doubted that Mulligan — with her cherubic cheeks, droopy eyes, and crooked smile — could effectively play Bathsheba, whose stern beauty, Hardy writes, belongs “rather to the demonian than to the angelic school.” Yet Mulligan admirably sharpens her own soft brand of beauty to suit the role, setting her jaw firmly when angry or distressed and flashing her big brown eyes at suitor and employee alike with all possible imperiousness. She moves perfectly, too. Every turn of the head or descent from a horse is quick, graceful, and impetuous, representing admirably Bathsheba’s propensity to throw all of her energy into every action, however large or tiny. Her performance adds one wonderfully light note into an otherwise stodgy production.
Unfortunately her vivaciousness overshadows the performances of her three costars, all playing oversized personalities in their own ways — Troy with his awfulness, Oak with his goodness, Boldwood with his madness. A crucial scene at Boldwood’s Christmas party is rendered meaningless because the camera lingers so insistently on Mulligan’s face that the viewer cannot access Boldwood’s perspective, which matters more than anything else as he steels himself to secure a promise of marriage from Bathsheba and instead meets disaster. This one poor choice neuters the story’s violent climax.
More than a properly impassioned Boldwood, though, I miss a solid Oak. Gabriel is more a man of action than of words, more a man to get things done than to do them in a unique way, so I imagine he must be a particularly difficult character to render interesting on screen. Still, Schoenaerts, who is obviously too good-looking for the part of a man whose features, in Hardy, “adhered throughout their form […] exactly to the middle line between the beauty of St. John and the ugliness of Judas Iscariot,” does almost nothing to distinguish him on screen. He might at least brood less and smile more. The miracle of Gabriel Oak, as Bathsheba realizes too late, is that
among the multitude of interests by which he was surrounded, those which affected his personal well-being were not the most absorbing and important in his eyes. Oak meditatively looked upon the horizon of circumstances without any special regard to his own standpoint in the midst.
It would be wonderful to see, on film, a representation of a rare character like this — essentially a representation of selflessness without pretensions toward martyrdom or glorification. Period and medium combine to make such a character nearly impossible to depict on screen. We as a culture like our protagonists to stay at the center of things, and films in particular must emphasize a given character’s centrality by lavishing screen time on him or her. Still, one day, I would like to see an adaptation of Far From the Madding Crowd in which a Gabriel Oak could play his critical role in an imagined world and be celebrated for it, but not at the expense of everything else in that world — human, sheep, dog, and otherwise.
Stephanie Bernhard is currently writing a dissertation at University of Virginia on modern agrarian literature.